How many emails a day or week can you remember that we focused on you? Say I get over 500 a day and of those 10% are marketing messages from brands I watch. Now of those, I see MAYBE 1-2 a day that are somewhat relevant and 1 that might be on target. Those that are on target are based on, what I find, two critical factors.
1. User profile information
2. Behavior: Reads, Actions
Don’t you all feel the same way? I am amazed that with all the data I KNOW email marketing professionals get from campaigns and then site stats that they can’t figure out how to make things relevant. The batch and blast mentality is still strong out there and we need to help one another to learn what to do.
Example of this in action (and why, sorry FishBowl, but does the restaurant industry think that Fishbowl is such a great solution? I am always let down with the creativity and time it must take to put these things together… just look at the “dynamic” use of inserting my name ABOVE the creative… and my kids are both under 6 years old.)

I spent some time on a call this AM with a new client helping them to understand segmentation and some simple ways to look at data. My first thing is: write 3 user stories. If you aren’t familiar with a user story well it is just this:
Identify 3 or more perceived customer types on your mailing list or who you are going after. Take a blank sheet of paper and write down what YOU think they might be wanting to get from you based on your product, services, or content. Then start testing with every campaign. I always rec spacing tests and next actions out about 10 days to see what the down wind effects of the campaign are on your site, call to action and then to have a secondary drop in place (I prefer postcard style with ONE call to action) to send to those that either did not read, did not click or did not convert. It is the shampoo method of email marketing… Lather, Rinse, Repeat.
There is not a silver bullet with email no matter what others may tell you. It is not a one shot medium, but a reactive one. I can attest that brands that mail me relevant emails get my attention and in the end my mind share or dollars. And after all, isn’t that what you want? If not, go back to postal DM and continue your slow uptick in 1% growth and take me off your list while you are at it.